In the course of my long career I have successfully supervised 17 PhD students – each wonderful in their own way. These students have contributed a lot to the various research projects described in my blog.
Sometimes I wonder if I give them due credit. To be on the safe side I’m going to present a complete list of all 17 with their contributions and their current situations.
I don’t rank my students, because each have their own strengths. And I don’t want to choose some for special superstar treatment. Instead, I’ll give the brief reports in chronological order.
In the beginning
So we begin with Azio (Tony) Faustini, my very first student. Tony is the son of Italian immigrants to the UK. He grew up in Leeds and still has a Northern accent. He was an undergraduate at the university of Warwick and soon after becoming a grad student asked to study with me. I happily agreed – smart move on my part.
For his PhD he proved the Kahn principal – that operational behaviour of a dataflow network is given by the least fixed point of the corresponding equations. He used infinite games in the proof, and pioneered this technique.
After graduating he stayed on as a research assistant and produced the first usable Lucid interpreter, as documented in the 1985 Lucid book.
He then left the UK for the US, first as a prof at Arizona State then at Sun and Microsoft, then with a Bay Area startup. He is now retired but collaborating with me on his eLucid8 project.
My next student was Forouzan Golshani, a Persian friend of Tony. Forouzan in his PhD devised a functional database query language. We lost touch after he graduated. He’s had an amazing career since then, eg writing over 200 articles, being a lifetime fellow of the IEEE, etc etc. He is currently a professor at Cal State Long Beach, where he was Dean of Engineering for several years.
After Forouzan came Paul Theo Pilgram, an anglophile from Germany. Paul’s PhD was on translating Lucid dataflow to message passing actors. He was so disciplined that the examiners found not even minor mistakes. After graduating he returned to Germany and had a successful career as a researcher at Siemens in Munich.
Next is Ali Yaghi. Ali’s family were Palestinian refugees from the Nakba and Ali grew up in a refugee camp in Jordan. His PhD was on a dataflow scheme for implementing functions in Lucid. The idea was to translate general recursion into branching time iteration. The result is what I call “Yaghi code” and is vital to the Lucid project, including the current eLucid8 work.
After graduating Ali returned to the mideast for successful careers in education in Kuwait and Jordan. He is currently general manager of Jordan’s Al Hussein Fund for Excellence.
The last person to join the Warwick group was Steve Matthews, a native Brit and friend of Ali Yaghi. His PhD was on domains wth a metric, so you can reason about termination. He later stayed on as a lecturer at Warwick, and collaborated with Ralph Kopperman in the US.
I return to Canada
In 1983 I left Warwick, for personal and professional reasons. I became a professsor at the University of Victoria (Uvic) in British Columbia, Canada. Ali Yaghi and Steve Matthews hadn’t graduated, and my former Warwick colleague David Park helped them complete their PhDs.
Once at Uvic I began looking for grad students and spotted a promising candidate named Weichang Du. Du was one of the first in what would become a wave of Chinese students coming to the West to study.
Du immediately took to dataflow and did an amazing Master’s on the intensional spreadsheet. We later collaborated on developing this idea. His PhD was on parallel intensional programming as was much of his research after graduating. He joined computer science at the University of New Brunswick and had a successful career there.
My next find was Mehmet Orgun, a well trained Turkish student (it turns out I’m good at spotting talent). His PhD research was on intensional logic programming (eg temporal prolog) and he proved a minimal model and completeness result. We collaborated on these ideas later on.
After graduating he joined computer science at Macquarie University in Sydney, Australia. There he proved to be a real over achiever. His CV lists over 300 articles, numerous grants, awards, memberships in professional societies etc.
(Incidentally I don’t equate success necessarily with big CVs. My own is relatively modest.)
Then I supervised Gordon Stuart, a former student of Dave Parnas, who had left Uvic. Gordon formalized the semantics of an idea of mine for equational axiomatisation of inheritance. After graduating he ran the computer science department at Camosun College in Victoria for many years.
Next I was lucky to have Panos Rondogiannis, a Greek master’s student, join me for a PhD. Panos proved the correctness of Yaghi code and extended it to handle some higher order programs. After graduating he eventually ended up at the University of Athens.
Unlike some of my other students he continued in the direction of his PhD. We have collaborated on higher order intensional programming and higher order logic programming. His CV is impressive by the conventional measures and he has been lucky/skilllful in attracting excellent masters and PhD students.
Meaanwhile my luck continued. Senhua Tao, Du’s wife, arrived from China keen to do a PhD, and I was keen to oblige her. She quickly produced a dissertatation on intensional attribute grammars, the idea being to have intensional operators to take you around the abstract syntax tree.
Tao is very practically oriented and didn’t pursue an academic position, instead had a successful career in industry.
My luck continued again with mc schraefel (lower case deliberate). I’ll simply point you at her website at the University of Southhampton in the UK.
Yet more luck
My next lucky stroke was Paul Swoboda, a bright undergraduate in my logic course. Paul is an expert hacker (in the good sense). He did a masters with me in the course of which he produced a versioned instance of Perl, which formed the basis for the implementation of intensional html. Paul moved to Australia and did a PhD with John Plaice at UNSW (I was co-supervisor).
Paul also passed on an academic career and became a free lance software engineer. He also works part time on an ambitious software system based on his PhD. We stay in touch.
Next I took on Rich Little, another Uvic masters student. Rich studied intensional versioned context free grammers and proved that the standard results still hold. He is now pursuing a teaching career at Uvic.
Some orphaned ideas
By now you have noticed a pattern, that a student does a PhD on a really interesting subject but then drops it after graduating. Sometimes they don’t even publish their results. This is a pity, but I totally understand it. They may be tired of the topic, or have other ideas they’re keen to pursue. Or a research career just may not appeal to them – academia can be a real rat race. They may prefer teaching or working in industry
I myself dropped what are now called “Wadge degrees” after graduating, and directed my energy to the Lucid project.
However these ideas are out there, waiting to be taken up.
The final group
About this time I developed what I called “infinitesimal logic” in which there are booleans which are less than fully true or more than fully false. My colleague Alex Thomo got interested and we co-supervised Maria Chowdhury, who showed the logic could be used for recommendation systems. Maria now works in industry, most recently at Microsoft.
If you’re counting you’ll notice that Maria is only my third female grad student. I wish I’d done better but in my defence I must say that computer science academia is not very welcoming to women. Oddly I had much better luck with masters students.
One day I came in to work and met a new neighbour in the office across from mine, a sessional named Milan Frankl. We hit it off and he became my next grad student. Milan, originally from Yugoslavia, emigrated to Canada long ago and had an interesting career in IT (IBM among others) and in business. His PhD was on the use of heuristics (‘rules of thumb’) in business.
After graduating Milan continued teaching and joined University of Canada West. He’s another over achiever: he has written 15 books covering a variety of topics including logic, business operation, IT, and, most recently, an introduction to AI and 5G networks. We’ve stayed in touch and are both fans of AI.
Speaking of AI, shortly before retiring I taught the department AI course (no one else wanted to; the department at that time wasn’t into AI). A bright student in the course, Omar Alaqeeli, asked to do a PhD and I accepted. His PhD was about a system for logic without bound variables that I invented. Omar showed that the standard results, eg completeness, carry over. Omar returned to his native Saudi Arabia and a career in academia.
My very last student, Monem Shennat, came from Libya. He was originally on a Libyan government scholarship but then the Libyan government ceased to exist (actually, split in two).
Monem took up the difficult task of dimensional analysis of multi dimensional programs – figuring out, for each variable which dimensions are actually relevant. He solved the hard problem of analysing programs with user defined recursive functions. The solution involves an instrumented test evaluation of the program.
Monem graduated at a bad time, with all the tech layoffs, and has had difficulty getting established.
So there you have it, 17 wonderful PhD students (I had some great masters students as well, but no room here to talk about them. Perhaps another post).
A surprise
My adviser – your ‘grand adviser’ – was John W. Addison Jr. Occasionally Addison would hold soirees in his house, typically when visitors were in town. One night I went to one of these soirees wondering who the visitors were.
They were Alonzo Church and Stephen Kleene.
In case you don’t recognize them, I can describe them in computer science terms: the guy who invented the lambda calculus (Church) and the guy who invented regular expressions (Kleene). Legendary figures before us in flesh and blood.
They seemed like modest, regular guys. I don’t remember our conversations.
Why were they there? Because both were closely connected to Addison. Kleene had been Addison’s adviser – your great grand adviser – and Church had been Kleene’s adviser. Yes, Alonzo Church is your great great grand adviser.
But there’s more: Church was Addison’s father-in-law. Addison married Mary-Ann Church, Church’s daughter.
Illustrious ancestors
The next obvious question is, who was Church’s adviser? None other than Oswald Veblen, the famous geometer/topologist. (I made heavy use of his ordinal functions in my PhD).
Continuing up this branch of the family tree (warning: all male) we come to E. H. Moore, one of the founders of the American Mathematical Society. Moore’s adviser was H. A. Newton. Newton built up Yale’s Math dept and made it the first US department to grant PhDs.
Now we come too Michel Chasles, who founded projective geometry. He in turn studied under Simeon Poisson, known for Poisson processes among other things.
With Poisson the trail gets murky because PhDs didn’t exist then. But Poisson had two famous mentors, J-L Lagrange and P-S Laplace. They in turn can be traced back to L Euler and J Bernoulli, but there the trail runs cold (Some argue that it goes back to Leibniz).
That’s the family my 17 students come from; I think they’ve lived up to their heritage.